Contextual Asessment Starter Questions

One of the greater frustrations I have experienced in the church I serve has not come from the people within the church as much as it has from well intended (I presume) outsiders and fringe folks who espouse a missional approach. This is surprising because I want to embrace a missional approach. But much of the advice I repeatedly get is to make implementation without regard for the context of the culture in which our church is set, and without regard to the understanding of the people that have long been within the church.

The models that these well-intended Christians admire (and the models these folks have often reminded me are far different from what I have to-date effectively implemented) look a lot like those models I read about from cutting edge missional churches in Seattle, Dallas, and Metro Atlanta. They are excellent examples of missional thinking put in practice. And it is exciting to read about what God is doing in those cities. But I don’t live in any of those places. Nor, obviously, does anyone who regularly attends our church.   Nor do any of our neighbors that God has put us here to love.

So, in short, the reality is that much of the well intended criticism I receive is by those who desperately want to be missional, but whose advice is not really so much “missional” as it is the imposing of particular personal preferences on a people through practices and structures.  The irony is that their advice is just as much driven by their own personal preference as are the practices of the “Traditional Church” these folks rail against.

One of the primary marks of missional is to actually exegete the culture where you live and worship.  It requires an understanding of the real values, the faith shapers and influencers, and the idols that may offer peculiar obstacles to the gospel specific to ones own area.

The question is, then, how to determine what those factors may be in a particular community or region.

I appreciate Jeff Vanderstelt who has compiled a list of questions he calls Centextual Assessment Starters.  These questions, if answered honestly, will help assess the community, which will enable you to develop a better understanding of the uniqueness of your community. Once we understand our community we are in a better position to think missionally and implement genuine contextualized missional strategies.

1. Do you know the story of the particular community or culture that you are called to?

2. If you know the story, what are the barriers to the gospel? List 3 Barriers to the Gospel.

3. What is the message and medium of the gospel for your community? Through what tangible forms would you demonstrate the gospel to your community? List 3 tangible ways to demonstrate the Gospel in “rhythm”.

4. In your community, do you know the personal life stories of any unbelievers? What are some ways you can get to know the personal stories of unbelievers around you?

5. What are the forms of celebration that unbelievers in your culture engage in?

6. How are you leading (or how could you lead) the believers in your community to either create celebrations that un-believers can engage in or join un-believers in their celebrations?

7. Does your faith community have a clearly identifiable “people group” and mission to whom they are focusing their prayers, activities and resources? If so, who is it? If not, how can you find one?

8. If the answer to #7 is yes, is there a group of believers working together toward that mission on a regular basis? And if so, how?

9. Do the believers that are working on mission together know each other’s life stories? Do you know the stories of the believers you are ministering with? How can you get to know teach other’s stories?

10. How often do the believers gather together to eat meals, celebrate and focus on a mission in their community together? What does this look like?

11. What form of serving do you think would best communicate the gospel to the community you live in?

12. Are you able to clearly articulate the Story of God (the gospel narrative)? How can you begin to tell The Story of God in a form that makes sense to your culture? List some ways to start.

13. Are the believers in your community equipped to know the Gospel Narrative (The Story of God) and demonstrate and declare it in culturally appropriate ways in their community? What are some ways you can start NOW to equip them to Tell The Story?

14. Would you say that the unbelievers in your community would grieve the loss of your church if your were to “close the doors” and the believers left the community? What would it look like to be the Church in such a way that the city would grieve if you all left?

More Questions for Personal Application…

Q: Are you aware of where the gospel could bring healing to your own life story? If so, where in your life story did you begin to believe a false gospel?

Q: How does the gospel re-inform your story?

Q: Which parts of the gospel narrative do you need to remind yourself of in order to both live out the gospel AND live out the mission of the gospel?

4 thoughts on “Contextual Asessment Starter Questions

  1. Good post Dennis. Great questions by Vanderstelt. ……..I have to disagree with you on this one however.

    There are a number of Churches as you know, in the area that are having a great impact on the culture of the area by being Gospel centered, Missional in purpose, and at the same time attractional because of Gospel centered teaching, desire to reach people with the Gospel and deliberate, purposed ministry.

    I think (my opnion anyway) the model used as you note in your post at these churches in larger cites of Dallas, Seattle, New York, etc… is not much different than whats being used in some of the growing and larger Churches in our area. Sure the culture is much more metropolitan (not sure of spelling) in the larger cities, but because of todays communications, with data phones, the net, face book, twetter, blogs, etc we have a really much smaller world and a much more connected world than a lot of folks believe.

    It’s that connectedness that really sets the tone for todays culture. Instead of Bibles at Church you see data phone apps in place of the traditional Bibles, large screens help illistrate teaching points, music is more “felt” through more modern instruments and upbeat songs, musical songs, even hymns. Where faith is put into action and not just discussed in “Sunday School” but lived out among people in small group settings. People involved in Missional Community and service. That the Church is more about movement & transforing hearts than a place.

    Yes Church today is more about movement and “being” and “living” the Gospel in our communities. No matter if it’s large or small. Because butts in the seats is a small measure for the most part.

    But… the Bible belt, the Traditional Church with it’s steeple & pews and tight denominational structures are still alive and well and in some areas are being true to the lived out Gospel and all the implications of that. But……many do not, and don’t see they are really ingrown and set agendas by what they always have in the past and really are tied to what they have always done and the world has changed around them and they hardly notice. They are just out of touch with sinners, the hurting, and the culture around them. Only if more of their people could be accused of hanging with sinners.

    So it’s not so much about what model is used, as much as the Gospel lived out by the Church in question……
    For me it’s never been about preference, it’s about reaching as many people as possible with the Gospel. Being part of a movement …………

    As far as those well intended Christians who try to encourage you …… might want to listen to what they are saying, it could have some truth in their words at times…..and it may not be just about prefrerence !

  2. Oh, if only there were several gospel-centered, missional churches in Bristol. That would be wonderful. But what I see is a number of “Church Growth Movement” ministries dressed up in missional and gospel-centered clothing because it sells right now. A little more charitable, there may be a handful of mission-centered churches…

    David, you and I have very different definitions of being gospel-centered.

  3. Yah I guess we do not sure. We need to discuss that at lunch one of these days. As I respect your wisdom, experience and your teaching. So if you think I’m off base I want to hear why.

    But I think you need to get out more and really take a look at what is happening around Bristol and the Tri-Cities as there are some really good Churches that are Gospel centered.

  4. Bt the way Dennnis, I wish I would have said this but Mark Dirscol did. “We don’t need more knowing…..we need more going….”

    Implications are exactly what James talks about. The Gospel is about reaching people and changing hearts.

    The Gospel that I know is all about Jesus and his love for his people. A Redemptive story we are intrusted with to bring people to him.

    So for me it’s about old fashion disciple making and reaching as many people as possible with the Gospel in every way possible.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s